(Associated Press via NewsEdge) The Paris Court of Appeal upheld record fines of 534 million euros ($704 million) against France's three biggest mobile operators for conspiring to undermine competition.
The appeal court upheld a December 2005 ruling by France's Competition Council that monthly exchanges of sales data among France Telecom, Bouygues, and Vivendi SA's SFR unit between 1997 and 2003 had broken antitrust laws.
The competition watchdog imposed its highest ever fines against the three operators in a 90-page report that cited, among other evidence, handwritten notes explicitly mentioning an 'agreement' among the three market leaders.
Reacting to the verdict, SFR said it 'regretted that its arguments have not been heard.' SFR argued unsuccessfully that the information-sharing had not broken antitrust rules because it concerned only past sales and not future projections.
The original ruling and appeal verdict are embarrassing for Finance Minister Thierry Breton, who took over as chairman and CEO of France Telecom the year before the illegal information exchanges stopped. Breton left France Telecom to join the government in February 2005.
France's biggest consumer organization, UFC-Que Choisir, welcomed the appeal verdict but said that under current French laws, the outcome would benefit only the 12,500 consumers on whose behalf it had filed its original complaint in 2002.
© 2006 The Associated Press
© 2006 Dialog, a Thomson business. All rights reserved