The advent of connected and autonomous vehicles (CAV) has the potential to cause major and disruptive changes to cities worldwide, a new report from Siemens indicates.
The report “Cities in the Driving Seat” stresses the need for cities to plan early and tackle the issue in a wider context of mobility transformations. Launched at the World Cities Summit in Singapore, the study explores the interdependencies between urban development, public transportation policies, power supply, pollution and the increasing share of CAV in city traffic.
Lack of mid-term planning and delayed investments in infrastructure could create negative social, economic and environmental effects, the authors from Siemens’ Global Center of Competence Cities argue.
“Autonomous vehicles must be part of a wider transformation of urban areas. Cities need to ensure that they work towards putting people first – and not cars, or we risk repeating the mistakes of the past. The future of our cities could look very different with the adoption of connected and autonomous vehicles and they could help shape future trends in climate change, air quality, public health and more,” said Pete Daw, Urban Development and Environment Director, Siemens Global Center of Competence Cities.
In addition, the report describes the key benefits and potential risks of autonomous vehicles. It examines scenarios for adopting autonomous vehicles which illustrate how outcomes could differ significantly depending on how they are adopted.
Benefits include:
- First and last mile trips that will strengthen public transport;
- Reduction of noise, air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions;
- Decrease of number of road fatalities and injuries; annually 1.25 million lives are lost around the world due to road collisions, with some 90% of these collisions the result of human error;
- Expanded mobility access to the young, elderly, impaired and marginalized;
- Repurposing of land currently used for parking and roadways into green space, housing, schools, protected cycle lanes, etc.
- Greater efficiencies and safety through the connection and communication of vehicles with city infrastructure
However, without clear and thoughtful policies and regulations the arrival of CAV could result in negative consequences, such as:
- Continuation of effects of climate change if CAV are not regulated to be low or zero-carbon;
- No decrease in vehicle ownership if individuals prefer their own CAV instead of adopting a shared transport system;
- Unused CAV may cause congestion and require unnecessary parking space;
- Increase of vehicle miles traveled if individuals alter their commute from walking, cycling or taking public transport to using CAV.
To maximize the benefits of automation and of the introduction of CAV, the report recommends harnessing the advance of four transformations in unison: automation, electrification, digital connectivity and shared mobility. Adopting mobility transformations in isolation could lead to adverse outcomes or detract from potential benefits. The study defines three possible scenarios to illustrate how outcomes could vary depending on the vision and policies that a city puts in place.
- The strong city scenario assumes that shared mobility becomes the norm and private car ownership declines, that parking space is unlocked and retrofitted as schools, hospitals, and new housing units and that most vehicles are electric and powered by clean energy grids.
- The business-as-usual scenario provides an outlook of future mobility that is not guided by a coherent vision or effective policies. The assumed revolutions in vehicle automation and electrification do not lift off at scale, and private usage remains the norm, little urban land is unlocked and only a minority of CAV are electric.
- In the CAV-as-a-luxury-good scenario CAV remain an exclusive rarity, private car-ownership is the norm, shared vehicles and shared trips remain a niche concept and public transport usage decreases rapidly over time. Vehicles promote individual trips and still utilize internal combustion engines, causing more CO2 emissions than ever before.
The full report can be downloaded here.
First published in eGov Innovation